This "D-Day" was oral "Defense Day" for my Ph.D. dissertation at Kent State University in Ohio. After the end of the 2-hour defense, the committee privately discussed the defense. As they talked behind the closed door, three of us - my wife, our friend Michael K and I - waited for their decision. "Congratulations, Dr. Coyle" were wonderful words to hear from my dissertation director and the rest of the committee.
I started my first doctoral class many years before on a warm sunny June day at Kent, a 100-mile drive each way from my home. There was quite a bit of snow on the ground the day of my defense - but the day couldn't have been better.
After a celebratory drink and dinner with my wonderful wife, it was back to Steubenville to grade my students' papers, projects and final exams.
I looked kind of tired Sunday night.
It's been quite a ride, especially this semster. And will be a wonderful Christmas!
Jim Coyle
